Well, io9 did also say that Trek had previously always tried to make the science believable, which made me gesticulate at the screen and say "What!?" a lot. But most of their other criticisms were spot on, yes.
(And, once I got over the fact that they were having that discussion where/when they were having it, well -- it was a great scene.)
The rest of it-- well, the fact that everyone spends So Much effort in order to bring Khan back for trial, and then they Khansicle him without (AFAIK) a trial, is basically a microcosm of all the rest of the logic and plot holes wandering around
Amaebi has explained Curate/Parson's Egg for me; sorry, I assume everyone knows my not-pop-culture references.
no subject
(And, once I got over the fact that they were having that discussion where/when they were having it, well -- it was a great scene.)
The rest of it-- well, the fact that everyone spends So Much effort in order to bring Khan back for trial, and then they Khansicle him without (AFAIK) a trial, is basically a microcosm of all the rest of the logic and plot holes wandering around
Amaebi has explained Curate/Parson's Egg for me; sorry, I assume everyone knows my not-pop-culture references.